A monthly cookie-forward subscription for the most enthusiastic bakery people.
The Anniemayniacs Club is a rotating monthly box featuring mostly cookies — with the occasional appearance of mini quick bread loaves, seasonal treats, sandwich cookies, or whoopie pies.
Each month’s lineup is thoughtfully curated:
60% brand-new flavors created exclusively for club members
40% classic favorites you already love
Always gluten free (Celiac safe), top 9 allergen free, and vegan
New flavors may include frosted cookies, stuffed cookies, creative flavor combinations, and seasonal varieties not available on the current market or online menus.
This is where I test, experiment, and bring back the best of the best.
Solo Box (6 items)
Share Box (12 items)
(Contents vary by month, but both tiers contain the same items — just different quantities.)
Boxes are available monthly for:
Local Pickup – First Saturday of every month at the farmer’s market located at 13060 Factory Lane, Louisville, KY 40245
Shipping – Boxes ship the first Tuesday of every month
(Ice packs included when necessary due to heat or melt-sensitive items.)
The Anniemayniacs Club is a curated subscription. To keep it sustainable:
No flavor swaps
No allergy substitutions
No email date changes
If you have a corn, oat, or dye allergy, please note that boxes may occasionally contain items with those ingredients and cannot be substituted.
The box is the box.
Monthly box flavors are released via the newsletter on the 19th of each month.
You have until the 24th to purchase that month’s box as a one-time order or to join the recurring membership.
Membership may be canceled at any time, but must be canceled before the next box is processed (on the 24th).
If you sign up on the 25th-31st of each month, it skips an entire month before your first box begins.
The Anniemayniacs Club was created to bring new flavors, seasonal creativity, and a little surprise into your month — without the overwhelm of a full custom menu.
If you like being first to try new things, this club is for you.
A monthly cookie-forward subscription for the most enthusiastic bakery people.
The Anniemayniacs Club is a rotating monthly box featuring mostly cookies — with the occasional appearance of mini quick bread loaves, seasonal treats, sandwich cookies, or whoopie pies.
Each month’s lineup is thoughtfully curated:
60% brand-new flavors created exclusively for club members
40% classic favorites you already love
Always gluten free (Celiac safe), top 9 allergen free, and vegan
New flavors may include frosted cookies, stuffed cookies, creative flavor combinations, and seasonal varieties not available on the current market or online menus.
This is where I test, experiment, and bring back the best of the best.
Solo Box (6 items)
Share Box (12 items)
(Contents vary by month, but both tiers contain the same items — just different quantities.)
Boxes are available monthly for:
Local Pickup – First Saturday of every month at the farmer’s market located at 13060 Factory Lane, Louisville, KY 40245
Shipping – Boxes ship the first Tuesday of every month
(Ice packs included when necessary due to heat or melt-sensitive items.)
The Anniemayniacs Club is a curated subscription. To keep it sustainable:
No flavor swaps
No allergy substitutions
No email date changes
If you have a corn, oat, or dye allergy, please note that boxes may occasionally contain items with those ingredients and cannot be substituted.
The box is the box.
Monthly box flavors are released via the newsletter on the 19th of each month.
You have until the 24th to purchase that month’s box as a one-time order or to join the recurring membership.
Membership may be canceled at any time, but must be canceled before the next box is processed (on the 24th).
If you sign up on the 25th-31st of each month, it skips an entire month before your first box begins.
The Anniemayniacs Club was created to bring new flavors, seasonal creativity, and a little surprise into your month — without the overwhelm of a full custom menu.
If you like being first to try new things, this club is for you.
